Business debt case studies
If you run your own company it might help to know that others have also struggled with business debts, and PayPlan have been able to help.
Please note: These case studies are based on real client experiences. Every financial situation is different and the options available will depend on individual circumstances. The outcome achieved in one case does not guarantee similar results for others.
1. Business Case Study – Mike
Mike was in paid employment earning a good salary. In an effort to advance his career he changed jobs but the company he went to work for never fulfilled its promises and he was eventually made redundant whilst he was on holiday.
Although this was a very stressful time for Mike he decided to set up in business for himself, initially in sales. However the companies to whom he contracted did not pay on time and he found himself without a regular income with the bills piling up.
Mike changed his business strategy and his business began to go from strength to strength. However, even though the business was now successful he was still unable to repay his credit commitment from the income he earned.
After reviewing Mike's circumstances, a range of debt solutions were considered. An Individual Voluntary Arrangement (IVA) was identified as the most appropriate option for his situation at that time. The arrangement was designed around what Mike could reasonably afford based on his circumstances at the time.
2. Business Case Study – Christine
Christine ran a successful company providing websites and computer software which won many awards within the computer industry.
However, the company was dissolved due to a lack of commitment from other directors. Christine decided to continue in business as a sole trader.
She took out business loans, which were taken out to fund ongoing trading and cover her employees wages.
Cash flow was poor however there was the prospect of large contracts being awarded and so Chris was not unduly worried. Unfortunately one very large contract was badly quoted for which meant that the business incurred a significant loss on this deal.
Christine was forced to make some staff redundant as she could no longer afford the wages, although some had to be retained as they were necessary to complete the unprofitable contract. At this point HMRC presented a petition for bankruptcy.
Bankruptcy would severely affect Christine’s ability to continue in business as contracts are of a long duration and she would need to be able to take deposits. It is an offence for an undischarged bankrupt to take credit (definition includes deposits) without disclosing the fact that they are an undischarged bankrupt. This would not have helped her business as most of the contracts were with large financial institutions. It was at this point she was recommended to contact us for an alternative solution.
We assisted Christine in the preparation of repayment proposals to all her creditors, including HMRC, in the form of an individual voluntary arrangement. Her proposal was accepted by creditors, allowing her to continue trading under the terms of the arrangement.
3. Business Case Study – John and Mary
John and Mary are taxi drivers. They got into financial difficulties due to a down turn in local business because of increased competition from other taxi firms.
Their only asset was their mobile home which was owned outright and they had no surplus income after paying all their household bills and living expenses.
Though bankruptcy was the best option for them they felt that they would like to have the opportunity of making an offer to their creditors.
They realised that if they went bankrupt they could lose their home anyway and so decided to sell the property and offer some of the funds to their creditors in full and final settlement.
The arrangement allowed them to keep some of the cash realised from the sale. In bankruptcy, a larger proportion of the proceeds may have been made available to creditors through the trustee.